Tag Archives: Right to be Forgotten

Europe’s Epistemological Crisis: Disinformation Threatens Democracy and Electoral Integrity

BRUSSELS, 21-Mar-2025 — /EuropaWire/ — Europe is confronting a deep-seated crisis in its collective understanding—a challenge that threatens the very foundation of democratic values. At WEF 2025, global leaders labeled the rapid spread of disinformation as the most urgent short-term threat, surpassing even the dangers posed by war and natural disasters. In regions at the forefront of 21st-century geopolitical struggles, misinformation is no longer merely a moral or social concern but a force capable of undermining political elections and destabilizing democratic institutions.

Robert Szustkowski, the driving force behind a pan-European initiative to halt disinformation, contends that the European Union must significantly boost its investments in high-quality journalism and advanced fact-checking tools. This, he argues, is essential to replace the void left by unreliable media platforms and to protect the public from manipulative narratives. Data from the EUvsDisinfo Lab reveals that countries like Poland have been hit hardest by these campaigns—with nearly 1,500 documented cases over the past decade, positioning Poland among the most vulnerable to Russian propaganda and other sources of false information, as noted by the nation’s Deputy Premier responsible for digital affairs.

Disinformation has evolved into a powerful political tool that can skew electoral outcomes and sway public opinion both locally and globally. European leaders are thus urged to implement a range of measures—from legal reforms and political initiatives to grassroots fact-checking platforms—that address the problem without compromising free speech or media independence. The Digital Services Act (DSA) offers a promising framework by mandating the monitoring and removal of illegal content while providing citizens a structured means to request the deletion of misleading information.

In Poland, proactive steps have already been taken ahead of the presidential elections. The government has established protective measures aimed at scrutinizing content across media channels and social platforms like X, TikTok, and Telegram. Krzysztof Gawkowski, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Digital Affairs, emphasized the critical need for vigilance, while Wojciech Głażewski, director at Check Point Software Technologies Poland, warned that the strategic manipulation of disinformation poses a severe risk to electoral integrity and democratic stability.

Community initiatives are also emerging as key players in this battle. Szustkowski’s proposal calls for extending the “Right to Be Forgotten” to media outlets and establishing a registry of personal rights violations, alongside appointing a Readers’ Rights Ombudsman to assist individuals harmed by false narratives. Such systemic changes are seen as vital to managing the disinformation crisis across Europe.

Ultimately, combating disinformation is not just a matter of legislative action; it also requires a robust civic education framework. A 2020 Eurobarometer study showed that 71% of Europeans regularly encounter disinformation and view its rapid spread as a grave threat to democracy. Empowering citizens with the knowledge to critically assess and counter false information is essential to preserving the integrity of democratic processes in today’s information-driven world.

SOURCE: EuropaWire

European Commission Reviews Poland’s Media Compliance with the Right to be Forgotten Amid Data Protection Concerns

european union blue and gold flags flying in the wind in brussels city in belgium.

BRUSSELS, 8-Oct-2024 — /EuropaWire/ — In a recent proposal presented to the European Commission on June 26, 2024, advocate Szustkowski has called for the empowerment of individuals to erase digital references that are deemed false, unsupported, or irrelevant, particularly in cases of defamatory media reports. He argues for the accountability of media entities regarding inaccuracies and defamation, alongside the need for standardized guidelines and mechanisms for reporting these issues.

In its response, the EU’s Data Protection Unit reaffirmed that the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) encompasses measures designed to safeguard personal data, applicable to both journalists and media organizations. Specifically, Article 17 of the GDPR grants individuals the right to request the removal of their personal data from data controllers. Should personal data be publicly shared, data controllers are obliged to inform those processing this data about any erasure requests.

The Commission clarified that, while personal data protection is crucial, it is not absolute. Guidelines within the GDPR indicate that data controllers are not required to delete personal data if such processing is essential to uphold freedom of expression and information. Nevertheless, member states are expected to strike a balance between the principles governing freedom of expression—journalistic freedom included—and data protection rights, as stipulated in Article 85 of the GDPR.

Acknowledging Szustkowski’s concerns, the European Commission emphasized the necessity for a careful balance that respects both data protection and journalistic integrity in any forthcoming actions.

The enforcement of data protection laws remains under the purview of national authorities, specifically data protection supervisory bodies and judicial courts. These entities are responsible for investigating alleged GDPR violations and adjudicating claims for compensation.

Expressing optimism about ongoing discussions with EU authorities, Szustkowski highlighted the insights from the Directorate-General for Justice & Consumers as crucial for future dialogues with Poland’s Personal Data Protection Office. He views this engagement as an important stride toward ensuring responsible management of personal data by news organizations in Poland.

The author of this initiative reiterated his dedication to pursuing legislative reforms within Poland and the wider EU. Among his proposals is the establishment of a Readers’ Rights Ombudsman within publishing houses to address grievances from individuals affected by media content, promoting amicable resolutions between freedom of expression and personal data protection. He also advocates for the creation of a standardized reporting form for personal rights violations across the EU.

“Essential changes are imperative. We must empower EU citizens to safeguard their reputations, which in turn will help rebuild trust and credibility in the media,” stated Szustkowski. His initiative aims not only to protect individuals but also to combat disinformation across the European Union.

SOURCE: EuropaWire